Comparison · 6×4 tractor unit · long haul at 19.3 t

MAN TGX 33.580 6x4, tractor unit (2020–2023) vs Scania S 580 A6x4

MAN TGX 33.580 6x4, tractor unit (2020–2023)

2020–2023 · 427 kW
38.6l/100 km
median; 35.6–46.8 across 42 declared configurations

Scania S 580 A6x4

2018–2022 · 427 kW
36.2l/100 km
median; 33–39.8 across 7 declared configurations
MAN TGX 33.580 6x4, tractor unit (2020–2023) and Scania S 580 A6x4 side by side
SpecificationMAN TGX 33.580 6x4, tractor unit (2020–2023)Scania S 580 A6x4
Vehicle formTractor unit for semi-trailer (BC)RegisteredTractor unit for semi-trailer (BC)Registered
Axle configuration6×4Declared6×4Declared
Registered new2020–2023Registeredcentral 90% of records2018–2022Registeredcentral 90% of records
Engine power427 kWDeclared427 kWDeclared
Engine displacement15.3 litresDeclared16.4 litresDeclared
GearboxautomatedDeclaredautomatedDeclared
Emission classNot recordedEURO 6, EURO VI C, EURO VI DRegistered
Gross vehicle weight28,000–33,000 kgRegisteredmedian 28,000 kg, over 2 registrations27,000–35,000 kgRegisteredmedian 30,000 kg, across 2 type-approval versions and 7 records without one
Kerb weightNot recorded10,175–11,070 kgRegisteredmedian 10,560 kg, over 10 registrations
WheelbaseNot recorded4,300–4,700 mmRegisteredmedian 4,500 mm, over 10 registrations
Overall length6,875–7,007 mmRegisteredmedian 6,875 mm, over 2 registrations6,630–7,100 mmRegisteredmedian 6,880 mm, over 10 registrations
Overall height3,750–4,021 mmRegisteredmedian 3,750 mm, over 2 registrations4,000 mmRegistered
Declared fuel, long haul38.6 l/100 km Declaredmedian; 35.6–46.8 l/100 km across 42 declared configurations36.2 l/100 km Declaredmedian; 33–39.8 l/100 km across 7 declared configurations
CO₂ per tonne-km52.37 g Declaredmedian; 48.28–63.42 g49.1 g Declaredmedian; 44.8–53.9 g

Fuel and CO₂: long haul at 19.3 t, 2022 declarations.

What the numbers actually say

There is 2.4 l/100 km between these two (6.6%). That is inside the 10% tolerance of declared figures, so on fuel alone neither is the better choice: at 120,000 km a year and an assumed £1.40 a litre the gap would be about 2,880 litres a year (£4,032). The declared figures for one of them alone span 11.2 l/100 km across its configurations, so the specification ordered matters more than the choice between these two.

Fuel over a year

120,000 km · assumed price
MAN TGX 33.580 6x4, tractor unit (2020–2023)46,320 litres
£64,848 at the assumed price
Scania S 580 A6x443,440 litres
£60,816 at the assumed price
At 120,000 km a year and an assumed £1.40 a litre; the price is an assumption, not one we track.